De Moor X:9: Providential Preservation, Part 2
[A fundraising update: We have almost reached 50% of the fundraising goal! Thanks be to God!
We still have some ground to cover. If you are being blessed by the translation work, please consider supporting the work and speeding it on its way. Click here to watch a brief video on the project.]
Moreover, Preservation is either Mediate, in which the use and subordination of Second Causes obtains, as we saw in § 6; but which are of a far different sort from the First Cause, and are able to be serviceable for mutual sustentation after the likeness of Means; but in such a way that those Second Causes, just as also those things for the preservation of which they are conducive, always need an immediate and omnipotent Influx of the First Cause, upon which all blessing and efficacy of the Means depends, Leviticus 26:26; Haggai 1:5-9. Or Preservation is Immediate, not only in those Creatures, which, as we saw above, are ordinarily preserved immediately by God: but also in those, which were normally sustained by means, Exodus 34:28; 1 Kings 19:8; Matthew 4:2.

Ordinary or Extraordinary; that is, when Means, either ordinary or extraordinary, are employed: thus in Ordinary Preservation bread has been granted in a natural way to man for his principal nourishment: but the Preservation was Extraordinary, when God fed the Israelites in the wilderness with Manna raining from Heaven, and gave them drink from Water rushing from the smitten Rock, so that He might indicate to them, that man does not live by bread alone, butכִּ֛י עַל־כָּל־מוֹצָ֥א פִֽי־יְהוָ֖ה יִחְיֶ֥ה הָאָדָֽם׃, that by every utterance of the mouth of Jehovah doth man live, Deuteronomy 8:3, that is, that man lives by every thing, which God is pleased by His omnipotent command to ordain for him as food and to bless the same. In the path of the Ordinary Providence of God man is bound by his own labor to seek and to obtain nourishment for himself, Genesis 3:19; 2 Thessalonians 3:10-12: but it was the effect of an altogether Extraordinary Providence of God, that God made use of ravens to feed Elijah day by day, 1 Kings 17:2-6.
In the Individual or in the Kind. In the Individual are preserved Spirits, and the Greater Bodies, both heavenly, as with the upper Heavens themselves also the host of the starry Heaven, the sun, moon, and stars; and also the earthly, as with the earth itself the cliffs and hills, hence called everlasting, Genesis 49:26. In their Kind God preserves the Lesser Bodies, both Animate and Inanimate, yet with the same Matter abiding in every Generation and Corruption of the Individuals; so that in the regular dissolution of a Creature, not by Annihilation absolutely, but only relatively by Corruption, neither does God totally remove His preserving power from the Creature unto its Annihilation; but only to the extent that it ceases to be what it previously was.
Now, in this variety of Preservation, God manifests His Wisdom, ἀνυπεύθυνον/ unaccountable Freedom, and perfect Independence of Creatures. In the Preservation of many things, Immediate and in the Individual, one may observe the Power, Constancy, and Majesty of God: in Extraordinary Preservation His Power combined with Independence shines brilliantly: in Preservation, Ordinary and in the Kind only, we again observe with Creatures’ dependence and vanity because of sin God’s Constancy and Power, who, with the dissolution of innumerable individuals notwithstanding, unto the present day looks to the preservation of the same kinds/species of so many and such diverse things.
Preservation is yet a Free Act of God. By the same reasons, from which in Chapter VIII, § 12, we evinced, that Creation is an Indifferently Free Action of God, one may also conclude the same concerning Preservation. For, if, 1. the Preservation of whatever Creatures were necessary on their part, the existence of those Creatures would not be contingent, those Creatures would also be truly Necessary, but thus consequently independent and eternal, indeed, God Himself. 2. The altogether perfect nature of the independent Cause postulates, that He is not bound to preserve Creatures any longer than He pleases; since the continued existence of His Creatures by no means pertains to the perfection of the first Being. And so the nature both of Creatures and of the Creator proves the Freedom of Preservation in general.

Hence by Absolute Power God could annihilate Creatures. This follows of itself, if Preservation is an Indifferently Free Act. Neither is it able to be pleaded, that Annihilation in itself is inconsistent with divine Constancy or Immutability: since, 1. abolition of an existing thing is no more opposed to those, than the new production of a thing not yet existing. 2. From the Annihilation of a thing it would be evident by the very event, that God willed that a thing of this sort should exist only for a time, after which it would be dissolved again without any change in the divine Will, and hence without any detriment to His Constancy; as BURMAN not incorrectly describes Annihilation, Synopsi Theologiæ, book I, chapter XLIII, § 16, Therefore, Annihilation is to be conceived in no other manner, than if God by His omnipotent decree and will should command, that a certain thing should be only for a certain time; with which elapsed, that thing would then cease to be; not by a new action of God, but by the cessation of the prior act, which had not reached its end, and whereby the thing would not be commanded to exist any longer.
Now, this Possibility of the Annihilation of Creatures on account of the Liberty of divine Preservation Theologians maintain is to be held against Descartes, who in Responsionibus ad Objectiones secundas, page 81, says, we do not hold any argument, which would persuade that any substance is able to perish: and against such followers of his, who contend, that God is not able to annihilate this entire universe, nor any part of it. Of which thesis the πρῶτον ψεῦδος, fundamental error, is observed to be, lest perhaps a place be made for imaginary Spaces; or lest that Idea of the World, as having no limits of extension, be endangered. Which πρῶτον ψεῦδος, fundamental error, BURMAN advances, when after those things that I just now mentioned as correctly asserted by him, in § 17 he continues: It is vain to ask, whether God could annihilate this universe, with the earth alone excepted? and whether there would then be a Vacuum? For, what could be here, and what would then be, we do not know, neither do we have any idea of that state: but, according to the Ideas of things that we now have, it is manifest that it could not be, because we are not able to conceive of it except by erring: but God is not able to be the cause of error: and so, if He had willed to do any such thing, He would undoubtedly have given to us a different Idea of the world and extension.
But how lame this discourse is in every respect, everyone readily sees: since thus, 1. the Ideas of all things are falsely supposed to be innate in us. 2. No less falsely are those Ideas considered as norms of real truth outside of ourselves. 3. Specifically, there is an appeal to a false Idea of the World, concerning which I disputed in Chapter VIII, § 34.
At the same time, our AUTHOR also acknowledges, that, although Preservation according to the Absolute Power of God is able to cease, yet God appears to have decreed the contrary for His own glory, which nevertheless is not able to be demonstrated concerning individual things: this observation is illustrated by argument, which I advanced in favor of the Existence of Providence from Reason, § 3, even indeed a Priori, in 3.א.β, with Chapter XXXIV, § 30, brought in for comparison.
To which observation it also seems permissible to me to add, that, although by the Absolute Power of God we most willingly acknowledge the possible Annihilation of Creatures physically considered; yet the matter to some extent is otherwise in the case of rational Creatures: since in these also obtains a moral σχέσις/relation to God as the Most Just Lawgiver and Judge. The Annihilation of irrational Creatures is most aptly able to be placed together with their Dependence upon God as the ἀνυπευθύνῳ/unaccountable Lord. But, whether the Annihilation of rational Creatures Ethically considered is able to be reconciled with good and evil Recompense, which God’s Goodness, Holiness, and Justice towards Creatures holy or impious, more or less implies; concerning this I very much doubt, comparing those things that were disputed in Chapter IV, § 46, 47: according to which those very divine Virtues appear to require the permanence of the rational Creature although contingent in itself, so that he might receive from God worthy rewards or punishments: by which thing, nevertheless, the divine Freedom does not suffer any loss; compare Chapter VI, § 7β.



Westminster Confession of Faith 5:1: God the great Creator of all things doth uphold,1 direct, dispose, and govern all creatures, actions, and things,2 from the greatest even to the least,3 by His most wise and holy providence,4 according to His infallible foreknowledge,5 and the free and immutable counsel of His own will,6 to the praise of the glory of His wisdom, power, justice, goodness, and mercy.7
1 Heb. 1:3.
2 Dan. 4:34,35; Ps. 135:6; Acts 17:25,26,28; Job 38,39,40,41.
3 Matt. 10:29,30,31.
4 Prov. 15:3; Ps. 104:24; Ps. 145:17.
5 Acts 15:8; Ps. 94:8,9,10,11.
6 Eph. 1:11; Ps. 33:10,11.
7 Isa. 63:14; Eph. 3:10; Rom. 9:17; Gen. 45:7, Ps. 145:7.
See Wendelin's shorter treatment of the Doctrine of PROVIDENCE!
www.fromreformationtoreformation.com/introductory-theology
Or, get the book! https://www.lulu.com/shop/steven-dilday/wendelins-christian-theology-volume-1/hardcover/product-yv54k5p.html?srsltid=AfmBOorEjy-Ia6DnMaLvqBdQbsDD_Uy8hj2ZKGyxUTu-TuT_6p1nRZJ0&page=1&pageSize=4
Study the Doctrine of PROVIDENCE with De Moor!
www.fromreformationtoreformation.com/de-moor-on-providence